What type of appointment would you like?

Back to Blog Menu

Carpet tiles and broadloom carpeting are two popular flooring options for homes and offices. Both offer softness, insulation, noise reduction, and aesthetic appeal. However, there are some key differences in the pros and cons of tiles versus broadloom to consider when choosing floor coverings.

Pros of Carpet Tiles

• Easier to Clean and Maintain - Carpet tiles can be easily pulled up and replaced when stained or worn. Damaged tiles can be swapped out without replacing the whole floor covering. They are also vacuumable, and professional steam cleaning is simpler than dealing with a wall-to-wall broadloom.
• Customizable Installations - Mixing and matching carpet tile color, texture, and size allows for more creative patterned layouts compared to broadloom. Different areas like hallways or communal spaces can use alternate tiles.
• Lower Lifetime Costs - Although the upfront cost of quality carpet tiles may be more than lesser-grade broadloom, the overall lifespan cost of carpet tiles is usually less. Factoring in easier cleaning, stain removal, and tile replacement compared to tearing up and landfilling entire wall-to-wall carpets every 5-10 years on average.
• Easier Installation - Modular carpet tiles use a peel-and-stick method or tack strips, avoiding the need for power-stretching and seaming of broadloom installations. This also lowers installation costs and allows for DIY use in smaller areas. No need to tear out baseboards either.
• Environmentally Friendly - Major carpet tile manufacturers now produce eco-friendly tiles made from recycled and sustainable resources. The modular nature also leads to less waste over the flooring lifetime. Broadloom carpeting is harder to recycle and often ends up in landfills.

Cons of Carpet Tiles

• Seams Visible - There will be obvious seams between carpet tiles that affect the aesthetic flow compared to seamless broadloom. However, improvements in tile manufacturing have reduced the gap size. Good installers can also arrange the tile layout to make these seams less noticeable.
• Not Ideal for Damp Areas - Carpet tiles handle spills, steam cleaning, and chair wheels better than broadloom. However, excessive moisture can compromise the tile adhesive leading to lifting, curling, or unnecessary replacement. Broadloom may be the better option for basements and laundry rooms prone to large spills or flooding.
• Potential Matching Issues - Varying production dye lots, textures, and wear over time can lead to obsolete or discontinued carpet tile being difficult to match with new replacement tiles. This may result in the need to replace more tiles for a consistent appearance.
• Heavy Traffic Wear - In extremely high foot traffic areas like public lobbies, broadloom carpeting often handles concentrated wear better than modular tiles. Although newer carpet tile construction improves durability issues.

Pros of Broadloom Carpeting

• Seamless Appearance - Broadloom carpeting provides an unbroken, flowing aesthetic to rooms with fewer visible seams than modular carpet tiles. For large open concept spaces, this gives a more expansive flow.
• Damp Area Use - Backings and installation methods allow broadloom carpeting to handle moisture and humidity fluctuations better than carpet tiles in areas like basements. This prevents lifting, curling, and adhesives being compromised.
• Potentially Lower Upfront Cost - Lower-end broadloom carpets can have a lower initial purchasing cost compared to quality carpet tiles. However, the long-term cost difference for cleaning, maintenance, and replacement often makes carpet tiles better value.

Cons of Broadloom Carpeting

• Harder to Keep Clean - Stains, dirt, wear, and inconsistencies in wall-to-wall broadloom are harder to spot clean and replace. Eventual replacement of entire areas is needed rather than just swapping individual carpet tiles.
• Challenging Do-It-Yourself Installs - Proper broadloom installing using power-stretchers, seam taping, and trimming for tack strips is more complex than modular peel-and-stick tiles. Few homeowners can install broadloom well themselves.
• More Wasteful - The inability to replace small sections of damaged or worn broadloom means old carpeting usually ends up being landfilled when replacements are needed after only 5-10 years typically. Carpet tile modular use has less waste and environmental impact.

When weighing up carpet tiles versus broadloom for residential or commercial spaces, consider the flooring location, usage levels, installation needs, maintenance abilities, and budget. The pros and cons outlined here for each option should help building owners and managers make informed carpet floor covering decisions. Speak to flooring specialists for further guidance about selecting between carpet tiles or broadloom based on your unique situation.

If you ever make the decision to go ahead and get carpets, feel free to buy them from us. Love your floors now, pay for carpets later! £600 instant credit from Pay As You Go Carpets makes it possible. £10 weekly installments.